This Wednesday’s #YALitChat on Twitter had the theme “Bests of 2009 in YA: Books, Music, Movies, TV, Anything!”
I’ve been thinking ever since.
So, to finish out 2009, here are my own lists of The Bests of 2009, one a day until it’s time to party like it’s ten years ago.
Bests in Television of 2009
I watch a lot of television.
There were several ways that I debated writing my countdown — best new shows, best overall shows, best characters, best moments. So rather than trying to choose only one, this list is less of a countdown than… an awards show, with lots of categories, pretty dresses, and shiny gold men.
Best New TV Show

Glee
This should not surprise anyone. Just as it was for me in high school, my love for show choir dramedy is a compulsion. Time seems to be measured this fall in minutes until Glee, and moments watching Glee.
Runner Up: The Vampire Diaries
Best New Season of a Returning Show

Castle
Any comedic crime drama about a novelist cannot be bad.
That is a statement just itching to be proven wrong, but until it is, Castle is king. There is no sophomore slump for this show, and I’ve loved seeing more of Alexis (Castle’s sage teenage daughter) and banter between secondary characters Ryan and Esposito. Castle is one of the few “cult appeal” shows that I think the second season surpasses the first in quality, and I’m eagerly looking forward for more.
One particular highlight was that the victim in the episode “Vampire Weekend” was clearly cast to resemble Robert Pattinson-as-Edward Cullen, and it amused me.
Runner Up: Bones
Biggest Shark Jumping Escapade

Heroes
Heroes has been moving downwind for a long time. I, personally, liked the second season. I liked West. I liked Claire/West. I liked Molly, and I still liked Mohinder. I thought that Monique’s power was awesome and that Micah was continuously the most fascinating character on the show. I loved Elle, Season Two Sylar, and GabriElle. I did not like Maya and Alejandro.
So of course, Molly is gone, West is gone, Micah is gone, Monique is gone, Elle is very very dead, and Maya has stuck around as persistently as the virus that seeps from her eyes.
And instead they give us a really creepy carnival… because who doesn’t love a good death-filled scuzzy carnival?… and some sort of plotline about Parkman and Sylar being each other? I can’t even follow that. Nor can I get behind it as a viewer.
And suddenly, because she is in college, and hot, Claire is a lesbian.
I am totally OK with Claire being a lesbian. I am not OK with how the show has handled that particular storyline, and I think that the ways it is shown are total cop-outs to try to regain male viewership.
Lame.
Runner Up: Criminal Minds
Best Bounce Back from Possible Shark Jumping

Bones
I have been nervous about Bones‘ eventual decline ever since the supreme awesomeness of season three’s Gormogon story arc concluded, because… well how could they beat that?
They haven’t beaten it, nor have they approached its level of intrigue, but Bones has been consistently excellent through the last two seasons, and seems to really be hitting its stride in the development of the whole slew of new characters introduced in season four.
Mister Nigel Murray makes my heart sing. Daisy doesn’t make me want to punch her in the face anymore. I do not like Wendell, but it’s because I actually dislike him as a character and not because he’s an unlikably written character.
It took a whole season, but Bones has its mojo back.
Runner Up: CSI: New York
Best Overall Episode

“Preggers,” Glee
Again, no surprise.
Runner Up: “Stress Relief,” The Office








